Philadelphia Criminal Defense Blog
Third Circuit: Pennsylvania Third-Degree Robbery Does Not Qualify as a Crime of Violence Under Federal Sentencing Guidelines
The Third Circuit held that Pennsylvania third-degree robbery under § 3701(a)(1)(v) does not qualify as generic robbery and ordered resentencing without the disputed federal enhancement.
Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire - Criminal Defense Lawyer
The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has held that Pennsylvania third-degree felony robbery does not qualify as a crime of violence under the federal Sentencing Guidelines provision at issue in United States v. White, No. 22-2197 (3d Cir. Nov. 6, 2026). Pennsylvania permits a conviction under this subsection for suddenly snatching property without overcoming the victim’s resistance. Generic robbery requires that additional force. The Court therefore vacated White’s federal firearm sentence and ordered resentencing without the disputed enhancement.
What Happened in United States v. White?
In June 2020, Philadelphia police responded to reports of a burglary at a Rite Aid. Officers saw the defendant running down an aisle with a gun in his hand. An officer tackled him, arrested him, and recovered a semiautomatic pistol. The defendant pleaded guilty to possession of a firearm by a convicted felon.
At sentencing, prosecutors argued that the defendant’s prior Pennsylvania third-degree robbery conviction qualified as a crime of violence. Under U.S.S.G. § 2K2.1(a)(1), the enhancement required the qualifying firearm and at least two prior felony convictions for a crime of violence or a controlled substance offense. Both sides agreed that the defendant’s firearm could accept a large-capacity magazine and that he had one qualifying prior conviction. The robbery conviction determined whether he had the second.
The district judge counted the robbery conviction. That increased the calculated advisory range from 100–125 months to 140–175 months. Because the firearm offense carried a 120-month statutory maximum when White committed it, the advisory sentence became 120 months. The judge considered the defendant’s troubled background, granted a downward variance, and imposed 110 months. White appealed.
Why Pennsylvania’s Robbery Definition Matters
The disputed conviction fell under 18 Pa.C.S. § 3701(a)(1)(v), which prohibits taking property from another person by force however slight during a theft. The Third Circuit had already held that this offense did not satisfy the Guidelines’ elements clause, which addresses offenses requiring physical force against another person. The defendant’s appeal concerned the separate enumerated-offenses clause, which specifically lists robbery.
A state’s decision to call an offense robbery does not automatically make it a qualifying federal sentencing predicate. Under the categorical approach, the court compares the elements of the state offense with those of generic robbery. If the state permits conviction for conduct that generic robbery does not cover, the conviction cannot support the enhancement on that basis.
The Third Circuit examined how Pennsylvania courts apply the statute. Pennsylvania permits a third-degree robbery conviction when a defendant snatches a purse or takes a wallet from a person who is aware of the taking, even if the victim does not resist. Pennsylvania therefore does not require prosecutors to prove that the defendant used force to overcome resistance.
The Third Circuit Rejected the Enhancement
Generic robbery requires force sufficient to overcome a victim’s resistance. The resistance can be slight, but the defendant must overcome it. A person who simply snatches money from someone’s hand and runs away has not necessarily used that degree of force.
The difference controlled the result of the defendant’s appeal. Because Pennsylvania third-degree robbery includes sudden snatching without resistance, the state offense covers more conduct than generic robbery. The Third Circuit held that it does not qualify under the enumerated-offenses clause.
The government relied on an earlier Third Circuit decision treating North Carolina common law robbery as generic robbery. Prosecutors argued that both states required only a small amount of force. The Court rejected that comparison because North Carolina requires force sufficient to overcome resistance, while Pennsylvania permits conviction based on the force needed simply to separate the victim from the property. Describing both requirements as minimal did not make them equivalent.
The defendant was sentenced under the 2021 Guidelines, which listed robbery without defining it. The Court also addressed the Sentencing Commission’s November 2023 amendment adding a robbery definition. That amendment adopted the same requirement of force sufficient to overcome the victim’s resistance and supported the Court’s analysis.
The Court vacated the defendant’s sentence and remanded for resentencing without the § 2K2.1(a)(1) enhancement. It did not overturn his firearm conviction or his prior state robbery conviction, and it did not specify the sentence the district judge must impose on remand.
The Takeaway
Defense counsel should examine the precise subsection of every prior Pennsylvania robbery conviction before accepting a federal crime-of-violence enhancement. White addresses third-degree felony robbery under § 3701(a)(1)(v); it does not decide whether every other form of Pennsylvania robbery qualifies. For a defendant with a conviction under that subsection, counsel should challenge an enhancement based on treating it as generic robbery and calculate the range without that predicate. Counsel should preserve the objection at sentencing and pursue it on appeal if the judge incorrectly counts the conviction.
Goldstein Mehta LLC Criminal Defense
Facing Criminal Charges or Appealing a Criminal Case in Pennsylvania? We Can Help.
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder.
We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.
PA Superior Court Recognizes a Passenger’s Privacy Rights Beneath the Seat
In Commonwealth v. Williams, all three judges recognized a passenger’s privacy interest beneath his seat, even without a bag. The majority nevertheless upheld the protective search.
Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire - Criminal Defense Lawyer
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has issued a published decision recognizing that a passenger can have a reasonable expectation of privacy in a firearm concealed beneath his seat, even when the car belongs to someone else and the firearm is not inside a bag. In Commonwealth v. Williams, decided November 10, 2026, all three judges agreed that the defendant had a protected privacy interest in the area the officer searched.
The defendant nevertheless lost the suppression appeal. A divided Court held that the officer had reasonable suspicion to conduct a protective search, reversed the order suppressing the gun and the defendant’s statements, and remanded for further proceedings. That result is disappointing, but the published privacy ruling gives passengers a clear answer to a recurring prosecution argument.
The Traffic Stop and Search
A Chester police officer stopped a Grand Marquis after observing very dark window tint and receiving a registration-check response indicating that the tag had no record. The vehicle continued for several blocks before stopping. The defendant occupied the front passenger seat.
The driver provided his license, registration, and insurance information. He also disclosed that he had a firearm and produced a license to carry it. The officer removed the driver and secured that gun. The defendant remained in the passenger seat while the officer spoke with the driver near the patrol car.
The officer noticed that the defendant’s shirt was raised above his bellybutton, his underwear was bunched unusually high, and he was breathing heavily. After other officers arrived, the officer directed the defendant out of the car and searched the area within his reach. He found a firearm beneath the passenger seat. The defendant later admitted that the gun belonged to him. The trial court suppressed the gun and his resulting statements, and the Commonwealth appealed.
The Court Recognized Privacy Beneath the Passenger Seat
The Commonwealth argued that the defendant could not challenge the search because he was a passenger who neither owned nor controlled the vehicle. Prosecutors acknowledged that passengers may have privacy interests in luggage but argued that the uncovered floor beneath the seat was accessible to everyone in the car.
The Superior Court rejected that argument. The Court explained that the gun was beneath the defendant’s seat, outside the driver’s view and access. By concealing it there, the defendant indicated that he intended to keep it private. The Court recognized that expectation as reasonable.
The absence of a bag matters. Earlier unpublished decisions had recognized passengers’ privacy interests in bags and their contents, including a bag beneath a passenger seat. The Williams majority adopted that reasoning even though the officer found the firearm itself under the seat. The Commonwealth could not defeat the privacy claim simply because the defendant had not placed the gun inside a container.
Judge Lane expressly agreed with the privacy ruling before dissenting on the legality of the search. All three judges therefore agreed on this issue. The Court did not give every passenger an automatic privacy interest throughout a vehicle. It recognized the defendant’s privacy interest based on where he concealed the firearm and its separation from areas open to the other occupant.
Why the Majority Upheld the Search
After recognizing the defendant’s privacy interest, the Court considered whether the officer had a lawful basis to search. The majority concluded that the officer could conduct a limited protective search because he reasonably suspected that the defendant was armed and dangerous and could gain access to a weapon.
The majority relied collectively on the area’s crime history, the dark window tint, the vehicle’s delayed stop, the defendant’s clothing, and his heavy breathing and rapid heartbeat. The officer did not see the defendant remove a gun or make a furtive movement. The majority nevertheless treated the position of his clothing as suggesting that he had removed something from his waistband.
The officer admitted that he had felt comfortable leaving the defendant alone in the car. The majority treated reasonable suspicion as an objective inquiry and held that the circumstances justified extending the stop and searching the passenger area regardless of the officer’s stated lack of concern.
Judge Lane would have upheld suppression. She emphasized the trial court’s findings that the officer had completed the traffic investigation and lacked a basis to prolong the detention. She also stressed his decision to leave the defendant unattended after observing the conduct that supposedly justified the search, and the appellate court’s obligation to respect supported factual findings.
The Takeaway
Defense counsel can now cite a published decision recognizing a passenger’s privacy interest in a concealed firearm beneath his seat without having to show that it was inside a bag. Counsel should establish the item’s location, concealment, and accessibility to other occupants, then challenge the officer’s justification for searching. The defendant lost on reasonable suspicion, but the Court squarely rejected the Commonwealth’s attempt to deny his privacy interest.
Facing Criminal Charges or Appealing a Criminal Case in Pennsylvania? We Can Help.
Goldstein Mehta LLC Criminal Defense
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder.
We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.
PA Superior Court Orders New Trial After Improper Use of Other Abuse Allegations
The Superior Court ordered a new trial because other abuse allegations did not establish a common plan and improperly bolstered the complainant’s credibility.
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has ordered a new trial after prosecutors introduced testimony about alleged sexual misconduct involving two other witnesses at the trial of an EMS chief accused of abusing a teenage volunteer. In Commonwealth v. Shields, decided November 6, 2026, the Court held that general similarities between the allegations did not establish a common plan, scheme, or design under Pennsylvania Rule of Evidence 404(b). The Court also found that the testimony improperly bolstered the complainant’s credibility. It vacated the defendant’s judgment of sentence and remanded for a new trial.
The Facts of Commonwealth v. Shields
The defendant was the chief of Yellow Breeches Emergency Medical Services. The Commonwealth charged him with sexual offenses involving A.R., a 15-year-old volunteer, during 2021. A.R. testified that the defendant initially touched her inappropriately and later engaged in sexual intercourse with her during overnight shifts and in a storage unit at the station.
Before trial, prosecutors sought permission to call two other witnesses. T.B. described incidents from 1998 and 1999, when she was a 14-year-old junior member of a different fire company and the defendant was a deputy chief. A.B. described conduct in 2022, when she was 19 and worked at Yellow Breeches. Her allegations included unwanted touching of her shoulders and the placement of his hand on her inner thigh during a training exercise.
The trial court admitted their testimony under the common-plan exception to Rule 404(b). Both witnesses testified before A.R. The jury convicted the defendant of all charges, and the court sentenced him to six and one-half to 17 years in prison. On appeal, the defendant challenged the admission of the other allegations.
The Superior Court’s Ruling
Rule 404(b) prohibits prosecutors from using other alleged misconduct to establish that a defendant has a bad character and therefore committed the charged offense. Prosecutors may offer that evidence for a permitted purpose, but in a criminal case its probative value must outweigh its potential for unfair prejudice. Calling the evidence a common plan does not satisfy that requirement.
The Superior Court explained that the common-plan theory requires either acts linked to achieve a previously conceived common goal or crimes so unusual and distinctive that they identify the same perpetrator. Broad similarities between the witnesses or the alleged conduct do not satisfy either alternative.
The Commonwealth did not establish a previously conceived plan. The allegations involving T.B. began approximately 23 years before the charged conduct involving A.R. Neither A.R. nor A.B. had been born when the earliest incident allegedly occurred. Prosecutors did not establish that the defendant had already formed a plan to abuse them decades later. The Court concluded that allegations of misconduct when opportunities arose did not establish the required common goal.
The Commonwealth also failed to establish a distinctive method identifying the perpetrator. The defendant did not argue that any witness had misidentified him. The Court held that identity was not at issue and that admitting the testimony under that theory would have been improper for that reason alone.
The Court separately examined the alleged conduct and found significant differences. The allegations involving T.B. concerned attempts to touch her breasts. A.R. described repeated touching followed by intercourse. A.B. described shoulder touching and contact during a training exercise with other people present. The defendant allegedly suggested overnight stays to A.R. and offered housing to A.B., but did not make a comparable suggestion to T.B.
The Commonwealth emphasized that the defendant was older than the witnesses, supervised them, and used his workplace authority. The Court found those general similarities insufficient. Prosecutors needed details establishing a distinctive method, and they did not provide them.
Why the Error Required a New Trial
The Court found that the remaining evidence of guilt was not overwhelming. The Commonwealth did not present physical or documentary evidence of guilt, and A.R. provided the only direct testimony establishing the charged offenses. The other witnesses could therefore improperly increase the jury’s confidence in her account while forcing the defendant to defend against additional allegations for which he was not on trial.
The prosecutor called both other witnesses before A.R. and discussed their allegations first during closing argument. The Court found that this sequence portrayed the defendant as a serial abuser before the jury heard from the complainant. The prosecutor also improperly suggested that jurors should convict him for conduct involving all three witnesses. The judge’s limiting instruction did not make the error harmless.
The Takeaway
Defense counsel should require prosecutors to explain precisely why other allegations are admissible under Rule 404(b). A shared workplace, similar ages, or a general claim of grooming does not establish the common plan required in Shields. Counsel should identify the differences between the incidents and challenge any effort to use other allegations to make the complainant seem more credible. When the court admits the evidence, counsel should preserve both the evidentiary objection and any improper use in closing. Shields gives defendants a basis to challenge convictions when prosecutors use other accusations in this way.
Facing Criminal Charges or Appealing a Criminal Case in Pennsylvania? We Can Help.
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder.
We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.
PA Superior Court Vacates Bail Denial in Drug Delivery Resulting in Death Case
The Superior Court vacated a bail denial because prosecutors failed to present adequate evidence of danger and the judge did not assess whether release conditions could address it.
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has vacated an order denying bail to a man charged with drug delivery resulting in death. In Commonwealth v. Washington, decided November 3, 2026, the Court held that the Commonwealth failed to present adequate competent evidence to justify holding the defendant without bail. The trial judge also failed to consider whether electronic monitoring or other release conditions could address any danger. The Court sent the case back for the judge to decide whether to impose monetary or nonmonetary bail and what conditions were necessary.
The Facts of Commonwealth v. Washington
The Commonwealth charged the defendant in Allegheny County in July 2026 with drug delivery resulting in death and related drug and communication offenses. Prosecutors alleged that he supplied a controlled substance to a woman who died from an overdose in September 2024. After the courts denied bail, the defendant sought nonmonetary release with electronic home monitoring.
Defense counsel argued that the defendant, who was 61, was neither a flight risk nor a danger to the community. He lived with his son, voluntarily participated in a police interview, and surrendered to police. His only felony conviction dated to the 1980s, his most recent conviction was a 2017 misdemeanor possession offense, and he had never failed to appear in court. Counsel also argued that he remained in the community for nearly two years after the alleged incident without further police contact.
Pretrial Services recommended against release. The Commonwealth’s only witness was the woman’s mother, who described her grief and asked the court to deny bail. She did not know the nature of her daughter’s relationship with the defendant and did not testify about his character or other circumstances showing that he would endanger someone if released.
The judge denied the bail motion. In explaining that decision, the judge relied on the seriousness of the charges, the county’s overdose death statistics, and the recommendations against release. The judge also independently reviewed the affidavit of probable cause, which the Commonwealth had not presented at the bail hearing, and relied on its account of alleged drug-related text messages. The defendant filed a petition for specialized review in the Superior Court.
The Superior Court’s Ruling
Article I, Section 14 of the Pennsylvania Constitution protects the right to bail, subject to exceptions for capital offenses, offenses carrying a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, and certain cases involving danger to a person or the community. The charges in the defendant did not automatically make him ineligible for bail. The Commonwealth therefore had to establish the requirements for denying bail based on dangerousness.
The Court explained that prosecutors must show it is substantially more likely than not that the defendant will harm someone if released and that the court cannot reasonably prevent that harm through any available bail condition. The Commonwealth must present a substantial quantity of legally competent evidence. The judge must assess the defendant’s circumstances and the available release conditions.
The trial judge did not perform that assessment. The Commonwealth did not introduce documentary evidence or testimony verifying the allegations in the affidavit of probable cause. The judge could not establish the defendant’s dangerousness solely from the hearsay allegations in that affidavit. The mother’s testimony also did not establish that the defendant would pose a danger if released.
The Court faulted the judge for concentrating on the charged offense without adequately considering the other relevant release criteria. Pennsylvania Rule of Criminal Procedure 523 directs bail authorities to consider matters such as the defendant’s age, family relationships, residence, criminal record, and history of appearing in court. Although the judge heard the defendant’s criminal history, the judge never explained how it justified denying bail.
The judge also failed to evaluate the proposed electronic home monitoring. Even if the Commonwealth had established that the defendant would harm someone upon release, the judge still had to determine whether available conditions could reasonably prevent that harm. The prosecutor did not address whether monitoring would be inadequate, and the judge never assessed the proposal.
The Superior Court vacated the order denying bail modification and directed the trial court to determine the type and conditions of bail. The defendant would remain detained until the trial judge made that decision. The Superior Court did not set a dollar amount or require release on electronic monitoring.
The Takeaway
A drug delivery resulting in death charge does not, by itself, authorize a judge to hold a defendant without bail. When prosecutors seek detention based on dangerousness, defense counsel should insist on competent evidence addressing both the claimed danger and the inadequacy of available release conditions. Counsel should present a specific release plan and develop the defendant’s history of court appearances, residence, and other relevant circumstances. If the judge denies bail without the required proof or assessment, a petition for specialized review allows the defense to challenge that decision before trial. Ultimately, this case reflects an understanding that bail is not punishment - it is to protect the community and ensure that a defendant shows up for court. The mere fact that charges are serious or the alleged victim’s family is upset does not justify holding someone who is presumed innocent without bail.
Facing Criminal Charges or Appealing a Criminal Case in Pennsylvania? We Can Help.
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder.
We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.