Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak Goldstein Wins Full Dismissal of First Degree Murder Charges

Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak Goldstein

Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire, recently won the full dismissal of first-degree murder charges in the case of Commonwealth v. DH. Prosecutors had charged DH with first degree murder, conspiracy, and firearms charges for a shooting incident which occurred in Philadelphia. The incident resulted in the death of one man and injuries to a surviving complainant.

DH retained Attorney Goldstein immediately upon learning that there were charges pending. Attorney Goldstein was able to help DH turn himself in safely and then moved for the charges to be dismissed at the preliminary hearing. At the preliminary hearing, the Commonwealth presented evidence that DH was present while one of his friends got into a physical altercation with the surviving complainant. DH watched the fight, and during the fight, one of the men even dropped a cell phone. DH picked it back up and handed it to him. The fight ended, and the two groups separated.

Video evidence then showed that DH and the two co-defendants both got into the same car and began to drive away. The decedent and the surviving complainant began to walk away on foot. The video then showed the car, which DH was allegedly driving, parking near where the two victims were walking. Video then showed the two co-defendants following closely behind the two victims while DH walked even further behind. At some point, the two victims turned around, began to argue with the two co-defendants, and one of the co-defendants allegedly pulled a gun and began firing. Those shots killed the decedent and injured the surviving complainant. The video showed that the three men then fled the scene. 

Prosecutors identified DH from the video evidence and charged him with first degree murder and related charges, arguing that he had conspired with the shooter to commit the murder because they were friends, had driven away in the same car, and had come back to the area together. Attorney Goldstein argued for a full dismissal at the preliminary hearing on the basis of the mere presence doctrine. Mere presence is a defense to a criminal conspiracy charge. Mere presence is the idea that just because someone is present at the scene of the crime or friendly with someone else who commits a crime does not mean that they are responsible for the actions of the other person. 

Here, there was no evidence that DH actually knew or in any way encouraged the shooter to commit the homicide. Instead, the evidence showed only that they were friends and that DH was nearby when the co-defendant began shooting. Accordingly, the Municipal Court judge dismissed all charges except the firearms charge. DH was then released on bail. Attorney Goldstein subsequently filed a motion to quash the firearms charge, and the Court of Common Pleas granted that motion. Accordingly, all charges were dismissed, and DH is a free man. 

Facing criminal charges? We can help. 

Criminal Defense Lawyers Zak Goldstein and Demetra Mehta

If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, and Murder. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.