Philadelphia Criminal Defense Blog
Third Circuit: Pennsylvania Third-Degree Robbery Does Not Qualify as a Crime of Violence Under Federal Sentencing Guidelines
The Third Circuit held that Pennsylvania third-degree robbery under § 3701(a)(1)(v) does not qualify as generic robbery and ordered resentencing without the disputed federal enhancement.
Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire - Criminal Defense Lawyer
The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has held that Pennsylvania third-degree felony robbery does not qualify as a crime of violence under the federal Sentencing Guidelines provision at issue in United States v. White, No. 22-2197 (3d Cir. Nov. 6, 2026). Pennsylvania permits a conviction under this subsection for suddenly snatching property without overcoming the victim’s resistance. Generic robbery requires that additional force. The Court therefore vacated White’s federal firearm sentence and ordered resentencing without the disputed enhancement.
What Happened in United States v. White?
In June 2020, Philadelphia police responded to reports of a burglary at a Rite Aid. Officers saw the defendant running down an aisle with a gun in his hand. An officer tackled him, arrested him, and recovered a semiautomatic pistol. The defendant pleaded guilty to possession of a firearm by a convicted felon.
At sentencing, prosecutors argued that the defendant’s prior Pennsylvania third-degree robbery conviction qualified as a crime of violence. Under U.S.S.G. § 2K2.1(a)(1), the enhancement required the qualifying firearm and at least two prior felony convictions for a crime of violence or a controlled substance offense. Both sides agreed that the defendant’s firearm could accept a large-capacity magazine and that he had one qualifying prior conviction. The robbery conviction determined whether he had the second.
The district judge counted the robbery conviction. That increased the calculated advisory range from 100–125 months to 140–175 months. Because the firearm offense carried a 120-month statutory maximum when White committed it, the advisory sentence became 120 months. The judge considered the defendant’s troubled background, granted a downward variance, and imposed 110 months. White appealed.
Why Pennsylvania’s Robbery Definition Matters
The disputed conviction fell under 18 Pa.C.S. § 3701(a)(1)(v), which prohibits taking property from another person by force however slight during a theft. The Third Circuit had already held that this offense did not satisfy the Guidelines’ elements clause, which addresses offenses requiring physical force against another person. The defendant’s appeal concerned the separate enumerated-offenses clause, which specifically lists robbery.
A state’s decision to call an offense robbery does not automatically make it a qualifying federal sentencing predicate. Under the categorical approach, the court compares the elements of the state offense with those of generic robbery. If the state permits conviction for conduct that generic robbery does not cover, the conviction cannot support the enhancement on that basis.
The Third Circuit examined how Pennsylvania courts apply the statute. Pennsylvania permits a third-degree robbery conviction when a defendant snatches a purse or takes a wallet from a person who is aware of the taking, even if the victim does not resist. Pennsylvania therefore does not require prosecutors to prove that the defendant used force to overcome resistance.
The Third Circuit Rejected the Enhancement
Generic robbery requires force sufficient to overcome a victim’s resistance. The resistance can be slight, but the defendant must overcome it. A person who simply snatches money from someone’s hand and runs away has not necessarily used that degree of force.
The difference controlled the result of the defendant’s appeal. Because Pennsylvania third-degree robbery includes sudden snatching without resistance, the state offense covers more conduct than generic robbery. The Third Circuit held that it does not qualify under the enumerated-offenses clause.
The government relied on an earlier Third Circuit decision treating North Carolina common law robbery as generic robbery. Prosecutors argued that both states required only a small amount of force. The Court rejected that comparison because North Carolina requires force sufficient to overcome resistance, while Pennsylvania permits conviction based on the force needed simply to separate the victim from the property. Describing both requirements as minimal did not make them equivalent.
The defendant was sentenced under the 2021 Guidelines, which listed robbery without defining it. The Court also addressed the Sentencing Commission’s November 2023 amendment adding a robbery definition. That amendment adopted the same requirement of force sufficient to overcome the victim’s resistance and supported the Court’s analysis.
The Court vacated the defendant’s sentence and remanded for resentencing without the § 2K2.1(a)(1) enhancement. It did not overturn his firearm conviction or his prior state robbery conviction, and it did not specify the sentence the district judge must impose on remand.
The Takeaway
Defense counsel should examine the precise subsection of every prior Pennsylvania robbery conviction before accepting a federal crime-of-violence enhancement. White addresses third-degree felony robbery under § 3701(a)(1)(v); it does not decide whether every other form of Pennsylvania robbery qualifies. For a defendant with a conviction under that subsection, counsel should challenge an enhancement based on treating it as generic robbery and calculate the range without that predicate. Counsel should preserve the objection at sentencing and pursue it on appeal if the judge incorrectly counts the conviction.
Goldstein Mehta LLC Criminal Defense
Facing Criminal Charges or Appealing a Criminal Case in Pennsylvania? We Can Help.
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder.
We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.
PA Superior Court: One Fire Means One Sentence for Arson, No Matter How Many Buildings Are Damaged
Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has just decided the case of Commonwealth v. Swift, 2026 PA Super 66 (Pa. Super. March 31, 2026), holding that the unit of prosecution for the crime of arson endangering property under 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 3301(c)(2) is each act of arson, and not each property endangered by that act. The court reached this conclusion by applying the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s recent analysis in Commonwealth v. Smith, 346 A.3d 1251 (Pa. 2025), which addressed the same question in the context of the closely related arson endangering persons statute. As a result, the Superior Court vacated the defendant’s judgment of sentence and remanded for resentencing, finding that the trial court had improperly imposed two consecutive sentences for two counts of arson endangering property when the defendant had set only one fire. This decision is significant for anyone facing arson charges in Pennsylvania because it limits the number of sentences a court may impose following a single act of setting a fire, regardless of how many properties are damaged.
The Facts of Commonwealth v. Swift
In July 2019, the defendant set fire to the home of his ex-girlfriend in Allegheny County. The fire caused substantial damage to that residence and also spread to the two adjoining residences on either side of the targeted home. Following a jury trial, the jury convicted the defendant of arson endangering persons under 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 3301(a)(1)(i), arson of an inhabited building under 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 3301(a)(1)(ii), and two counts of arson endangering property under 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 3301(c)(2). The two counts of arson endangering property arose from the fire spreading to and damaging the two neighboring residences, not from the fire set to the ex-girlfriend’s home itself.
On June 28, 2023, the trial court sentenced the defendant to five to ten years’ imprisonment for arson endangering persons and two consecutive terms of fifteen to thirty months’ imprisonment for each of the two counts of arson endangering property. The defendant filed a timely appeal challenging, among other things, the imposition of separate sentences for the two arson endangering property convictions as an illegal sentence.
The Procedural History
The defendant’s sentencing challenge raised a question that was already working its way through the appellate courts. In his initial appeal, the defendant relied on the analysis set forth in the dissent in the Superior Court’s en banc decision in Commonwealth v. Smith, 298 A.3d 1140 (Pa. Super. 2023). At that time, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court had granted allowance of appeal in Smith but had not yet issued a decision. The Superior Court panel in the defendant’s case denied relief and affirmed the judgment of sentence.
The defendant then sought allowance of appeal with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. While that petition was pending, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Smith, reversing the Superior Court and holding that the unit of prosecution for arson endangering persons under Section 3301(a)(1)(i) is each act of arson, not each person endangered. On January 15, 2026, the Supreme Court granted partial relief to the defendant, vacated the Superior Court’s order affirming his judgment of sentence, and remanded the case for reconsideration in light of the new Smith decision. The Supreme Court’s remand order limited the issue to whether the trial court had imposed an illegal sentence by imposing separate, consecutive sentences for the two counts of arson endangering property.
The Superior Court’s Decision on Remand
On remand, the Superior Court applied the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Smith to the arson endangering property statute and reached the same conclusion: the unit of prosecution is each act of arson, not each property endangered.
The court’s analysis began with the text of the two statutes. The arson endangering persons statute, Section 3301(a)(1)(i), criminalizes intentionally starting a fire and thereby recklessly placing another person in danger of death or bodily injury. The arson endangering property statute, Section 3301(c)(2), uses identical language for the initial element, “intentionally start[ing] a fire or caus[ing] an explosion,” and then provides that the defendant must “recklessly place[] an inhabited building or occupied structure of another in danger of damage or destruction.” The Superior Court observed that the two statutes share the same structure: an intentional act of setting a fire, followed by a recklessness element involving harm to either persons or property.
The Supreme Court in Smith had determined that the arson endangering persons statute was ambiguous because the statutory language was capable of two reasonable interpretations: that the unit of prosecution was each act of arson, or that it was each endangered person. The Superior Court in Swift found that the arson endangering property statute, given its identical structure, was similarly ambiguous. The language could reasonably be read to mean that the unit of prosecution was either one act of arson or one damaged building.
Having found ambiguity, the court turned to the factors set forth in the Statutory Construction Act, 1 Pa.C.S.A. § 1921(c), which the Supreme Court had relied on in Smith. These factors include the occasion and necessity for the statute, the circumstances of its enactment, the mischief to be remedied, the object to be attained, and the consequences of a particular interpretation. The Superior Court incorporated the relevant discussion from Smith, in which the Supreme Court had reviewed the legislative history of Pennsylvania’s arson statutes. That history showed that the original penal statutes, written when the state was primarily rural, imposed severe penalties for burning structures important to an agricultural economy while providing inadequate penalties for fires that endangered life in urban settings. The modern Crimes Code replaced that scheme with a system that distinguishes only between arson endangering persons (a first-degree felony) and arson endangering property (a second-degree felony). Critically, the Supreme Court found nothing in the legislative history to suggest that the legislature intended to allow separate convictions and sentences for each individual endangered by a single act of arson.
Finally, and most critically, the Superior Court applied the rule of lenity. Because Section 3301 is a penal statute, any ambiguity must be resolved in the defendant’s favor. The Supreme Court in Smith had emphasized that the rule of lenity is not merely a convenient tool of statutory construction but is rooted in fundamental principles of due process, which require that no individual be forced to speculate about whether his conduct is prohibited.
Applying these principles, the Superior Court held that the unit of prosecution under the arson endangering property statute is each act of arson, not each damaged building or occupied structure. Because the record established that the defendant committed only one act of setting a fire, to his ex-girlfriend’s home, the trial court had erred in imposing separate sentences for the two counts of arson endangering property. The court vacated the defendant’s judgment of sentence and remanded to the trial court for resentencing.
The Takeaway
Commonwealth v. Swift is a significant sentencing decision for defendants facing arson charges in Pennsylvania. By extending the Supreme Court’s holding in Smith from the arson endangering persons statute to the arson endangering property statute, the Superior Court has now established that neither subsection of Section 3301 permits the imposition of multiple sentences based on the number of people endangered or properties damaged by a single fire. Instead, the unit of prosecution for both offenses is the act of setting the fire itself. A defendant who sets one fire can receive only one sentence for arson endangering persons and one sentence for arson endangering property, regardless of how many people were placed at risk or how many buildings were damaged.
This is an important development because arson cases frequently involve damage to multiple structures as fires spread. A defendant who sets fire to one building may cause damage to several neighboring properties. Under the prior approach, prosecutors could charge a separate count of arson endangering property for each building that sustained damage, and the trial court could impose a separate sentence for each count. Swift puts an end to that practice. While the defendant may still be convicted of multiple counts, the trial court may only impose a single sentence for the arson endangering property offense when the charges all arise from one act of setting a fire.
Facing Criminal Charges or a Wrongful Conviction?
Goldstein Mehta LLC Criminal Defense
If you are facing criminal charges or believe that the prosecution engaged in misconduct in your case, we can help. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder. We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our experienced criminal defense lawyers are typically available for same-day phone consultations and in-person meetings so that we can begin investigating your case, obtaining exculpatory evidence, and planning your defense. Call 267-225-2545 for a free criminal defense strategy session.
The New 2024 Pennsylvania Sentencing Guidelines
Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire
A major update to the Pennsylvania Sentencing Guidelines went into effect on January 1, 2024. The new guidelines significantly revamp Pennsylvania’s system for sentencing defendants following a conviction at trial or guilty plea. The guidelines had largely been handled the same way since their creation, but now, the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing has significantly changed the way prior record scores are calculated and created a very different sentencing matrix. The old guidelines still apply to offenses committed before 2024. The new 8th edition of the guidelines apply for offenses committed on or after January 1, 2024.
What are the sentencing guidelines?
As an introductory reminder, prior to sentencing a defendant in Pennsylvania state court, a judge must calculate the guidelines for the offense. Every offense has an offense gravity score, and every defendant has a prior record score. The judge must correctly determine the offense gravity score (OGS) and the defendant’s prior record score (PRS). Where those two numbers meet on the sentencing guidelines matrix then provides the judge with a recommended range for the minimum sentence. With the exception of very short sentences (like 30 days in jail for possession of marijuana), every sentence in Pennsylvania must have a minimum and a maximum. The maximum must be at least double the minimum in order for the sentence to be legal.
Under Pennsylvania’s guidelines system, the judge must correctly calculate the sentencing guidelines and then consider sentencing the defendant within the range provided by the guidelines for the defendant’s minimum sentence. Ultimately, the judge does not have to sentence the defendant within the guidelines. The judge could decide there is something less serious about the case and go below the guidelines or something more serious about the case and go above the guidelines. Guideline sentences, however, are very difficult to appeal. It is generally easier to appeal a sentence when the judge departs from the guidelines.
The basic idea of the new guidelines is the same; every offense will have guidelines based on an offense gravity score and a prior record score. Calculating those numbers, however, has become a little bit more complicated.
The Offense Gravity Score
The offense gravity score is relatively easy to determine. The Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing provides a list of offenses, and each offense has a numerical offense gravity score that goes with it. First, the defense attorney must determine the offense gravity score for each offense charged by reviewing the list of offenses in the complaint or bills of information. It is important to look at the specific subsection charged as different subsections may have different offense gravity scores.
Second, the attorney must determine whether any enhancements apply. The two most common enhancements are the deadly weapon possessed and the deadly weapon used enhancements. They apply when a deadly weapon like a gun or a knife was either used or possessed during the commission of the crime.
If a deadly weapon was possessed but not used, then the offense gravity score will be two points higher.
If the deadly weapon was used, then the offense gravity score will be three points higher.
The deadly weapon enhancements do not apply if the statute itself always involves the use of a deadly weapon because the use of a deadly weapon is an element of the offense. Possessing an instrument of crime, prohibited offensive weapons, possession of a weapon on school property, assault with a deadly weapon, and violations of the uniform firearms act do not require the application of the deadly weapon enhancements because the possession or use of a deadly weapon is part of the offense.
There are three other enhancements which are less likely to apply.
First, there is a school zone enhancement. If a controlled substance was delivered or possessed with the intent to deliver in a school zone, then there is a one point addition to the offense gravity score.
Second, there is a criminal gang enhancement of two points.
Third, there is a domestic violence enhancement of two points. If the defendant committed the offense against a family or household member, then the enhancement may apply.
It is important to accurately calculate the offense gravity score. Further, the calculation of the correct offense gravity score may be subject to litigation. If the Commonwealth alleges that a particular object was a deadly weapon but the object was not a gun or a knife, it may be possible to argue that the object was not actually a deadly weapon.
The defense should carefully review the pre-sentence investigation and calculation of the guidelines and object if the guidelines seem too high or are based on allegations the Commonwealth may not be able to prove. It is important to remember that the Commonwealth bears the burden of establishing that an enhancement applies by a preponderance of the evidence. It is not necessarily the defense attorney’s job to prove that it does not apply. The Commonwealth, however, may use circumstantial evidence in order to meet this burden.
The Prior Record Score
Second, the defense attorney must properly calculate a defendant’s prior record score. The system for determining the offense gravity score did not change significantly with the enactment of the new guidelines, but dealing with the prior record score is very different. Instead of looking at each charge for which a defendant has been convicted and assigning points to that charge and then adding those points up, the prior record score will now be based on the most serious offense of conviction for each case where a defendant was convicted of a crime.
There are four categories of offenses.
First, there are misdemeanors which have not been designated as serious crimes (POG1 offenses).
Second, there are third degree felonies and unclassified felonies (like possession with the intent to deliver) which have not been designated as serious crimes (POG2 offenses).
Third, there are serious crimes, first-degree felonies, and second-degree felonies (POG3 offenses). VUFA offenses and SORNA offenses are generally considered serious crimes that fall within the third category.
Fourth, there are crimes of violence which would otherwise be considered strike offenses (POG4 offenses). These include offenses like first-degree felony aggravated assault, attempted murder, rape, IDSI, and certain robberies and burglaries. There are other offenses which fall within this list. They are defined in 42 Pa.C.S. § 9714(g).
In calculating the prior record score, the defense attorney must determine which prior offense on the defendant’s record is the most serious. The attorney should then determine how many offenses of the same seriousness fro which the defendant has been convicted. The number of offenses for which the defendant has been convicted of the same seriousness will then determine the defendant’s prior record score based on where that number falls on this chart.
The Prior Record Score Matrix
For example, using the above chart, a defendant with two misdemeanors (which go under the POG1 category) will fall under prior record score one.
A defendant with two F1 robberies (which are crimes of violence that fall under POG4) will have the highest prior record score of four.
A defendant with three prior possession with the intent to deliver cases, which fall under POG2, will fall under prior record score three.
A defendant with two VUFA convictions (POG3), would have a prior record score of three.
Lapsing of Convictions for the Prior Record Score
Under the old guidelines, convictions were permanent. Even if a defendant was convicted of an offense fifty years ago, the offense would still count towards the defendant’s prior record score unless the offense was a juvenile adjudication and a certain amount of time had passed in between the adjudication and new offense. Now, convictions will no longer count if a defendant goes a certain amount of time in between arrests.
Juvenile Adjudications
First, juvenile adjudications lapse relatively quickly.
Juvenile adjudications for POG1 offenses (mostly misdemeanors) do not count towards the prior record score.
Juvenile offenses in POG2 (mostly third-degree felonies and PWIDs) do not count once the defendant turns 25.
POG3 offenses (felony ones and felony twos that are not crimes of violence) do not count if the defendant is “crime-free” for ten years.
Finally, POG4 adjudications (crimes of violence) do not count after 10 years crime-free if they were committed when the defendant was between 14 and 16 or after 15 years crime-free if the defendant was 16 or older.
Adult Convictions
Under the old guidelines, adult convictions counted forever. Now they may lapse after a certain amount of time.
POG1 offenses lapse after ten years from the conviction date even if the defendant was not crime-free.
POG2 and POG3 offenses lapse after 15 years of being crime-free.
POG4 offenses lapse after 25 years of being crime-free.
The time period for being crime-free runs either from the date of release from incarceration or the date of the sentence if the defendant received probation.
Again, if there is a dispute, the Commonwealth bears the burden of proving that lapse should not occur.
The following is the definition of a crime-free period:
‘‘Crime-free period.’’ Following a conviction and sentence and subsequent release to the community, the completion of a prescribed period of time without commission of a new felony or misdemeanor, for which the person pleads guilty or nolo contendere or is found guilty. For non-confinement sentences, release to the community begins on the date of sentencing; for confinement sentences, release to the community begins on the date of initial release on parole, or release following completion of the confinement sentence, whichever is earlier.
The New 2024 Pennsylvania Sentencing Guidelines Matrix
Once the criminal defense attorney has calculated the offense gravity score and prior record score, the next step is to see where those numbers meet on the below matrix. That number then provides a recommended minimum sentence for the judge to consider. The judge may go higher or may go lower, but the judge must properly calculate the guidelines and consider them. The judge must put the guidelines on the record, and if the judge decides to go above or below the guidelines in sentencing the defendant, the judge must announce the reasons for the departure on the record at the time of sentencing. The failure to properly calculate the guidelines or put the reasons for a departure on the record could be the basis for a successful appeal.
The New 2024 Pennsylvania Sentencing Guidelines Matrix (8th Edition)
A Judge May Depart From the Guidelines
Finally, a judge may depart from the guidelines. Judges may consider the following factors when deciding whether to depart:
(i) Nature and circumstances of the offense:
(A) Neither caused nor threatened serious harm.
(B) Conduct substantially influenced by another person.
(C) Acted under strong provocation.
(D) Substantial grounds to justify conduct.
(E) Role in offense.
(F) Purity of controlled substance.
(G) Abuse of position of trust.
(H) Vulnerability of victim.
(I) Temporal pattern.
(J) Offense pattern.
(K) Multiple offenses in a criminal incident.
(ii) History and character of the person:
(A) No history of criminal conduct.
(B) Substantial period of law-abiding behavior.
(C) Circumstances unlikely to recur.
(D) Likely to respond affirmatively to probation.
(E) Imprisonment would entail excessive hardship.
(F) Accepts responsibility.
(G) Provides substantial assistance.
(H) Compensated victim or community.
(I) Character and attitude.
(J) Treatment for substance abuse, behavioral health issues, or developmental disorders or disability.
(2) Unless otherwise prohibited by statute, the consideration of validated assessments of risk, needs and responsivity, or clinical evaluations may be considered to guide decisions related to the intensity of intervention, use of restrictive conditions, and duration of community supervision.
(3) Adequacy of the prior record score. The court may consider at sentencing prior convictions, juvenile adjudications, or dispositions not counted in the calculation of the PRS, in addition to other factors deemed appropriate by the court.
Obviously, this is a big list of reasons for a potential departure. At the end of the day, it is important to remember that the new guidelines, like the old ones, are not mandatory minimums. They provide the judge with a starting point for the potential sentence. In some counties, the guidelines are treated almost as mandatory minimums and it is rare to see judges go below or above the guidelines. In others, the guidelines are routinely calculated but then ignored. Additionally, the guidelines do not tell the judge whether to impose consecutive or concurrent sentences for different offenses. It is also not clear yet whether separate cases which were consolidated and disposed of at the same time will count as one case or two cases for calculating the prior record score, so some of these things will still be subject to litigation. Either way, it is important to correctly calculate the guidelines as they will give the defendant an idea of what they are facing if they are convicted and the improper calculation of the guidelines at sentencing could be the basis for an appeal or PCRA claim.
Facing criminal charges or appealing a criminal case in Pennsylvania? We can help.
Philadelphia Criminal Lawyer Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, and Murder. We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.
United States Sentencing Commission Votes to Eliminate Status Points
Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire
The United States Sentencing Commission has voted both to eliminate status points for most federal criminal defendants under the federal sentencing guidelines as well as to make that change retroactive. Until recently, the Sentencing Commission had not had a quorum of commissioners since 2018, so the Commission had been unable to propose changes to the federal sentencing guidelines. Now that a quorum of commissioners has been appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate, the Sentencing Commission is once again able to enact changes to the guidelines. Generally, the changes which receive a majority vote from the commissioners go into effect unless overturned by Congress within a 180 day review period.
What are status points?
Under the current federal sentencing guidelines, each defendant that is found guilty by a judge or jury or who pleads guilty receives an Offense Level and a Criminal History Score. The offense level is based on the seriousness of the offense. Offenses typically have a base offense level for the offense of conviction, and then there are all sorts of potential enhancements that may apply depending on the way in which the offense was committed.
For example, a wire fraud conviction would have a certain base offense level, but then the offense level would increase based on the amount of money lost by the victims of the fraud as well as other potential factors such as whether the defendant used sophisticated means to commit the fraud or had a leadership role in the scheme. Other enhancements may potentially apply in any given case.
During the pre-sentence report process, each defendant will also then be assigned a criminal history category based on their criminal history points by the United States Probation Officer who prepares the pre-sentence report. The criminal history category is generally based on the number and type of convictions that the defendant has previously received as well as the length of any sentences served for those convictions.
The sentencing guidelines, which provide a recommended sentence in months that the judge must consider imposing, are then calculated based on where the offense level and criminal history category meet. This chart shows the recommended sentencing range for each offense level and criminal history category.
Federal Sentencing Guidelines Matrix
The judge is not required to impose a guideline sentence, but judges take the guidelines extremely seriously.
Under current law, most offenders who are under probation, parole, or federal supervised release supervision at the time of the commission of the new offense receive two additional points towards their criminal history category for being under supervision at the time of the offense. Two points can often be the difference between specific criminal history categories, resulting in much higher guidelines for a defendant who is under supervision than one who is not. This can have a big impact on the recommended sentencing range.
For example, a defendant with an offense level of 34 and a criminal history category of II would be facing sentencing guidelines of 168 - 210 months’ incarceration. If the individual was under supervision at the time of the offense, the criminal history category could be increased to category III, and then the defendant would instead be facing 188 - 235 months’ incarceration. This means the defendant could receive an additional two years at the high end of the guidelines, so the difference can be significant.
Now, the federal Sentencing Commission has voted to eliminate status points for most defendants. Specifically, the Sentencing Commission abolished all status points for people who had fewer than seven accumulated criminal history points driving their criminal history category. For those with seven or more points, only one status point would be added rather than two. In making this change, the commission determined that status points had little to no relevance in the accurate determination of a criminal history profile.
Will the change to status points under the federal sentencing guidelines be retroactive?
On August 24, 2023, the Sentencing Commission also voted to make the change retroactive and to allow inmates who would be affected by the change to file motions to reduce their sentences starting in February 1, 2024. Defendants may not file motions to reduce their sentences before that date, but if a defendant received status points that affected their guideline range, the they may petition the district court for a reduction in sentence based on the retroactive change in the sentencing guidelines. This change also assumes that Congress does not vote to overturn the proposed amendment to the guidelines.
Ultimately, the Sentencing Commission determined that status points do very little to predict whether a particular defendant is likely to re-offend. Therefore, whether or not someone was under supervision at the time of the offense should no longer be factored into the guideline calculation going forward.
Facing criminal charges? We can help.
Goldstein Mehta LLC Criminal Defense Lawyers
If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, and Murder. We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.