Philadelphia Criminal Defense Blog
PA Superior Court: Prosecution May Not Introduce Facebook Posts Without Proving Defendant Authored Posts
When can the prosecution use Facebook messages against the defendant?
Criminal Defense Attorney Zak Goldstein
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has just decided the case of Commonwealth v. Mangel. In Mangel, the Superior Court held that the trial court properly denied the Commonwealth’s motion to admit supposedly incriminating Facebook messages against the defendant because the Commonwealth failed to prove that the defendant wrote the messages.
Commonwealth v. Mangel
Mangel involved the assault of a man at a graduation party. Prosecutors charged the defendant with Aggravated Assault, Simple Assault, and Harassment after the complainant told police that several fights ensued as a result of multiple people arriving uninvited at the party. The complainant stated that as he was walking away from the fights, he was struck in the back of the head, knocked to the ground, and repeatedly punched and kicked by the defendant and a co-defendant. The complainant did not know either defendant and had not spoken with them during the party, but he was able to identify them after family members showed him Facebook photos of the defendants. The complainant suffered facial lacerations, broken bones, and lost several of his teeth during the assault.
The Admission of Facebook Evidence
In order to prove the case against Mangel, the prosecution sought to obtain his Facebook records. The prosecution obtained a court order directing Facebook to provide records to them. The Commonwealth then filed a Motion in Limine asking the trial court to permit the introduction of screenshots of certain pages of a Facebook account for a “Tyler Mangel.” The screenshots showed various online and mobile device Facebook messenger messages. The Commonwealth also sought to introduce a photograph from the Facebook account of bloody hands which had been posted by a different individual on the Tyler Mangel page.
The trial court conducted a hearing on the Motion in Limine. At the hearing, an Erie County Detective attempted to authenticate the messages and photos for the Commonwealth. After being qualified as an expert witness in computer forensics, the detective testified that she had been asked to determine the owner of the Tyler Mangel profile page by the prosecution. In order to do so, she searched Facebook for the name Tyler Mangel. She testified that only one result appeared. She then compared that page to the screenshots that the prosecutors had given to her. She determined that both the screenshots and the page that she found bore the name Tyler Mangel, listed the account holder as living in Meadville, PA, and that some of the photographs on both the screenshots and the Facebook page were the same. The about section of the page also provided that the individual attended Meadville High School and that the username associated with the Facebook account was Mangel17.
The detective requested subscriber records from Facebook. Using those records, she determined that when the owner of the account created it, that person provided the name Tyler Mangel and email addresses with the name Mangel in them. The account was also linked to a specific cell phone number. The detective obtained a court order for Verizon records and traced the cell phone number to Stacy Mangel and a specific address in Meadville, PA. The court took judicial notice that this was the same address listed as the address for the defendant in the Criminal Complaint.
The detective concluded that the screenshots the Commonwealth wanted to introduce must have come from that account because both accounts 1) had the same name, 2) listed the account holder as living in Meadville, 3) listed the account holder as having attended the same high school, and 4) displayed photographs of the same individual. The trial court, however, asked the detective if she could provide that opinion to a reasonable degree of computer and scientific certainty that the account belonged to the defendant and whether the detective could testify that no one else accessed and posted things on the account. The detective testified that she could not provide that opinion with any certainty.
In addition to not being certain that no one else could have owned or used the Facebook account, the detective also confirmed that she did not obtain an IP address for the Facebook account. The defense lawyer also searched for the same name on his own phone and found five listings for Tyler Mangel. Finally, the detective did not link the cell phone information which she had obtained to the defendant.
The trial court denied the Commonwealth’s Motion in Limine to admit the Facebook evidence, and the prosecution appealed. The Superior Court affirmed the decision of the trial court. The Court found that the prosecution had simply failed to prove that the account belonged to the defendant, that the defendant had sent the messages in question or posted the pictures, and that the account could not have been used by someone else to do so. The Court also dismissed the Commonwealth's argument that the detective should not have been required to testify to a reasonable degree of certainty, noting that it is well-settled that all expert witnesses must be able to provide their opinions to a reasonable degree of certainty in the relevant field of study.
The Authentication of Facebook Messages in a Criminal Case
The Superior Court noted that there is relatively little case law in Pennsylvania on authenticating Facebook evidence and text messages in criminal cases. In general, Pennsylvania Rule of Evidence 901 provides that authentication is required prior to the admission of evidence. The party that seeks to introduce evidence must show to the court that the evidence is what it purports to be. In some cases, that can be shown through the testimony of a witness with personal knowledge. For example, had a friend testified that they had watched the defendant access the Facebook account, that could have been sufficient to show that it was the defendant’s account. Here, the prosecution had no direct evidence or witnesses with personal knowledge that could link the account to the defendant.
When the party seeking to admit the evidence does not have a witness with personal knowledge, the evidence may be authenticated through circumstantial evidence. Circumstantial evidence involves the appearance, contents, substance, internal patterns, or other distinctive characteristics of the item, taken together with all the circumstances surrounding it.
Here, the circumstantial evidence simply did not prove to a sufficient degree of reliability that the account belonged to the defendant or that the defendant had posted the information which the prosecution sought to introduce. Facebook accounts, like email and messaging accounts, can be accessed from any computer or smart phone with the appropriate user identification and password. The Court noted that social media presents unique challenges because of the great ease with which a social media account may be falsified. A legitimate account may also be accessed by an imposter.
In some cases, there may be sufficient circumstantial evidence with which to authenticate a social media account. Therefore, the Court ruled that social media evidence must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis to determine whether or not there has been an adequate foundational showing both of its relevance and its authenticity. The proponent of the evidence must show either direct or circumstantial evidence that tends to corroborate the identity of the author of the message or post. This could include testimony from the person who sent or received the communication, or contextual clues in the communication tending to reveal the identity of the sender. For example, if a message from the defendant's account arranged a meeting with a witness and then the defendant showed up to the meeting, the circumstantial evidnece would suggest that it was the defendant's account. However, social media can easily be hacked and forged, so the mere fact that an account has a person’s name or photo on it is simply insufficient to show that the account belongs to that person. The party introducing the evidence must be able to show more than that.
Here, the trial court properly prohibited the admission of the evidence because the prosecution showed only that the account appeared to belong to the defendant. The defendant never admitted ownership of it, and the prosecution did not call any witnesses to testify that they had communicated with the defendant using that account. Anyone could have created the account, added photos, and claimed that they went to Meadville High School and were Tyler Mangel. The prosecution also failed to provide date and time stamps to show when the posts were created, and the posts were ambiguous and did not clearly reference the allegations in the case. Accordingly, the Superior Court agreed with the defense attorney that the evidence was not sufficiently relevant and authentic. Therefore, it upheld the trial court’s ruling excluding the Facebook screenshots.
FACING CRIMINAL CHARGES? WE CAN HELP.
Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyers Zak Goldstein and Demetra Mehta
If you are facing criminal charges, we can help. Our Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers have successfully defended thousands of cases in state and federal courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We offer a complimentary 15-minute criminal defense strategy session to any potential client who is facing criminal charges or who may be under investigation by law enforcement. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.
PA Appellate Court Again Recognizes False ID to Law Enforcement Statute Requires Police to Explicitly Inform Defendant That They Are the Subject of an Official Investigation
Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak Goldstein
False Identification to Law Enforcement
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has just decided the case of Commonwealth v. Kitchen. In Kitchen, the court once again recognized that Pennsylvania’s False Identification to Law Enforcement Statute requires the Commonwealth to prove that the officer specifically informed the defendant that he or she was the subject of an official investigation prior to the defendant providing false identifying information to the officer. The court once again rejected the Commonwealth’s argument, which has been made repeatedly in prior cases, that the Commonwealth may prove a violation of the statute by showing that a defendant should have inferred the existence of an official investigation.
Commonwealth v. Kitchen
In Kitchen, Philadelphia police pulled the defendant over for making a right turn without activating her turn signal. The defendant pulled over, and police approached the vehicle. The officer testified that he asked the defendant for her license, registration, and insurance. The defendant did not have any paperwork for the vehicle, and she told the officer that she had rented the car. She also could not provide any paperwork for the car rental. After failing to provide any paperwork to the officer, the defendant gave the officer a fake name.
After the fake name she gave came back as a person with a suspended driver’s license, the officer decided to impound the vehicle. The officer used Philadelphia’s Live Stop procedure and called the Parking Authority to come tow the car. The officer removed the defendant from the car and conducted an inventory search of it. The officer found 76 packets of crack cocaine during the inventory search as well as a driver’s license with a different name on it from the name that the defendant had provided. The officer found additional packets of cocaine and some money throughout the car.
After finding more drugs and what may have been the defendant's real driver's license, the officer questioned the defendant further about her name. He told her that he believed that the name she had previously provided was actually the name of her girlfriend and that he had discovered that both the name provided and the name on the driver’s license he had found had suspended licenses. By this point, he had removed her from the vehicle and placed her in handcuffs, but she continued to give a fake name. The officer eventually arrested the defendant and charged her with Possession with the Intent to Deliver, False Identification to Law Enforcement, and related charges.
Is It a Crime to Give a Police Officer a Fake Name?
The defendant was found guilty of all charges in the trial court after the trial court ruled that she should have inferred from the circumstances that she was under official investigation for a violation of law. The defendant appealed, and the Superior Court reversed the conviction for False ID to Law Enforcement. Pennsylvania’s False ID statute simply does not make it a crime to merely provide police with a fake name. Instead, the statute provides:
A person commits an offense if he furnishes law enforcement authorities with false information about his identity after being informed by a law enforcement officer who is in uniform or who has identified himself as a law enforcement officer that the person is the subject of an official investigation of a violation of law.
Thus, the statute requires that a defendant first be informed that the person is the subject of an official investigation of a violation of law. Trial courts and prosecutors have frequently tried to argue that defendants should be expected to infer that they are under official investigation for a violation of law from the circumstances, meaning that if a defendant is placed in handcuffs and interrogated by police officers, the defendant should realize that they are under investigation and therefore be able to violate the statute. The courts have rejected this theory repeatedly. Instead, as the court again recognized in Kitchen, the statute requires the police to actually speak to the defendant and explicitly tell them that they are under official investigation for a violation of law. If the officer does not testify to having made that statement to the defendant, then a defendant cannot be properly convicted of False ID to Law Enforcement for providing a fake name or other incorrect identifying information. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court had already reached this conclusion in the case of In re D.S., and here, the Superior Court found that the rule still applies. Accordingly, the Court reversed the defendant’s conviction for false identification to law enforcement.
Award-Winning Philadelphia Criminal Defense Lawyers
Criminal Defense Attorneys
If you are facing criminal charges, we can help. Our experienced and understanding defense attorneys know the law and will use it to your advantage. We offer a free 15-minute criminal defense strategy session to every potential client. If you have been arrested or believe you may be under investigation, call us at 267-225-2545 to speak with an attorney today.
Getting Arrested Is Not a Probation Violation in PA
The PA Superior Court has just decided the case of Commonwealth v. Moriarty, finding that trial counsel was ineffective in failing to challenge the trial court’s finding that a defendant violated his probation solely by incurring an arrest on new charges.
Philadelphia Criminal Lawyer Zak Goldstein
Is Getting Arrested a Probation Violation?
The Superior Court has just decided the case of Commonwealth v. Moriarty, finding that violation of probation counsel was ineffective in failing to challenge the trial court’s finding that the defendant violated his probation solely by incurring an arrest on new charges. Moriarty involved the appeal of a Post-Conviction Relief Act (“PCRA”) Petition.
Commonwealth v. Moriarty
In Moriarty, the defendant first pleaded guilty to Recklessly Endangering Another Person and Resisting Arrest. Pursuant to the negotiations, the trial court sentenced the defendant to one to twenty-three months and twenty nine days of incarceration on the REAP charge and one year of consecutive probation on the Resisting Arrest charge. The court then immediately paroled the defendant, thereby releasing him from custody. The terms of the probation and parole provided that he would commit a violation thereof by committing any other crimes.
Daisy Kates Motions
The defendant was subsequently arrested on a new case and charged with Aggravated Assault and Terroristic Threats. The defendant’s back judge immediately lodged a probation detainer and appointed a defense attorney to represent the defendant. The Commonwealth, likely fearing it would not be able to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, filed a motion to revoke probation prior to the resolution of the defendant’s new Aggravated Assault case. This type of motion is called a “Daisy Kates” motion. A Daisy Kates motion asks the back judge to find the defendant in violation even though the defendant has not yet been convicted in the new case.
The constitutionality of these motions is currently debatable in light of the recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court case of Commonwealth v. Arter, but the defense failed to raise that issue in this case. The burden of proof in these types of probation hearings is lower than the beyond a reasonable doubt standard of a criminal trial. Instead, the Commonwealth must show that the defendant committed the crimes charged only by a preponderance of the evidence, which is a much lower standard. It is not uncommon for prosecutors to proceed in this manner when they have concerns that they may not be able to obtain a conviction at trial. These hearings are outrageously unfair both because the burden of proof is lower and the judge who will rule on the defendant’s guilt knows that the defendant has committed crimes previously and is on probation. Thus, the judge is already prejudiced against the defendant prior to hearing the evidence because the defendant was on the judge’s probation at the time that the defendant picked up the new case.
The probation court scheduled a Daisy Kates hearing while the new charges were still pending against the defendant. At the hearing, the defendant’s back judge asked defense counsel if he wished to say anything on behalf of the defendant. Counsel responded that he had consulted with his client and the probation department and that he agreed with the actions that would be taken. In other words, counsel agreed that the defendant should be found in violation of his probation and parole. The judge asked the defendant if he acknowledged the violations of his probation or parole, and defense counsel interjected that the violations were that he had been arrested on new charges. The defendant agreed, so the court found him in violation of his probation and parole and sentenced him to his back time followed by an additional year of probation on the Resisting Arrest charge.
Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
Of course, the defendant was eventually acquitted in the new Aggravated Assault and Terroristic Threats case which served as the basis for the supposed probation violation. The defendant promptly filed motions seeking immediate parole, reconsideration of his sentence, and a Post-Conviction Relief Act Petition alleging that probation counsel had been ineffective in failing to challenge the alleged probation violation. The court granted the motion for immediate parole but denied the other motions, including the PCRA Petition. The defendant appealed.
The Appeal
On appeal, the Superior Court found that probation counsel had in fact provided ineffective assistance of counsel in failing to challenge the alleged probation violation. Counsel was ineffective because the Commonwealth proved only that the defendant had been arrested on new charges and waived the preliminary hearing on those charges.
In order to win a PCRA based on the ineffective assistance of counsel, a petitioner must show that counsel was ineffective, counsel lacked a reasonable, strategic basis for the actions taken in the representation, and that the petitioner was prejudiced due to the counsel’s failures. Here, the Superior Court concluded that counsel was ineffective in failing to challenge the probation violation.
An Arrest Is Not a Probation Violation
First, the Superior Court noted that an arrest, standing alone, does not constitute a probation or parole violation under Pennsylvania law. This is true even where a defendant waives the preliminary hearing as a preliminary hearing does not end in a finding of guilt. Instead, the Commonwealth must introduce at least some evidence beyond the mere arrest and waiver of a preliminary hearing to show that a violation of probation occurred. Typically, the Commonwealth must call at least some live witnesses to show that the defendant committed a crime. Here, the Commonwealth did not introduce any other evidence, so counsel was ineffective in conceding a probation violation based on an arrest alone.
Second, the Court held that the defense lawyer had no reasonable, strategic basis for failing to challenge the violation. Although defense counsel testified that he had recommended conceding the violation so that the defendant would be sentenced and thereby become eligible for work release, it actually turned out that the defendant was not eligible for work release under the general terms of work release enacted by the County Prison. Thus, the defendant gained nothing other than a 23 month jail sentence by failing to fight the alleged probation violation.
Third, the Court held that the defendant was prejudiced because he was sentenced to jail. Had the defendant asked the trial court to defer the probation violation hearing until the new case was resolved or challenged the Commonwealth’s ability to prove that he committed a crime, the defendant may have been released without any additional sentence. Notably, the Court suggested that it is preferable that probation violation hearings not take place until new charges are resolved because of the possibility that a defendant could be found in violation at a Daisy Kates hearing for committing a crime for which the defendant will later be acquitted at trial.
Given that the defendant established all three prongs of the test, the Superior Court granted the PCRA and vacated the trial court’s order revoking probation and re-sentencing him. The Superior Court went further and found that the defendant did not violate his probation. Therefore, it ordered the trial court to re-instate the original sentence and provide the defendant with time credit towards that sentence for the time spent in custody.
Award-Winning Philadelphia Probation Violation Lawyers
Philadelphia Criminal Defense Attorneys
If you or a loved one are facing a potential probation violation or probation detainer, we can help. In many cases, it may be possible to have the detainer lifted pending the resolution of a new case or to seek alternatives to incarceration for established violations of probation. Our Philadelphia criminal defense attorneys have successfully helped thousands of clients navigate Gagnon I and Gagnon II probation hearings. We are also able to provide sueprior We offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding advocate today.
PA Superior Court: Drug Overdose Response Immunity Statute Applies to Person Overdosing
Criminal Lawyer Zak Goldstein
The Superior Court has just decided the case of Commonwealth v. Lewis, holding that Pennsylvania’s Drug Overdose Response Immunity statute provides immunity for both the reporter of a drug overdose and the victim of a drug overdose, so long as the conditions of the statute are met. It also applies even where the victim of the overdose makes the call for help themselves and there is no separate reporter. Pennsylvania’s drug overdose immunity statute is very limited and does not provide immunity against serious felony charges, but this is a good opinion which encourages people who may be in the middle of a drug overdose to seek help instead of worrying about whether they will be arrested for minor drug offenses.
Commonwealth v. Lewis
In Lewis, the defendant called 911 from her hotel room to report that she had overdosed on prescription pills. Police responded and took her to the hospital. While assisting her, police saw more pills and paraphernalia for smoking marijuana in her room. The police questioned her about the drugs, and she admitted that they belonged to her and that she smokes marijuana. Lewis received treatment at the hospital and recovered. Prosecutors, of course, charged her with possession of drug paraphernalia.
Prior to trial, Lewis moved to dismiss the charges, claiming immunity to prosecution under the Drug Overdose Response Immunity statute. The trial court denied the motion. The trial court ruled that the act did not apply to her case because 1) Lewis did not actually need immediate medical attention, and 2) the Act did not apply to self-reported overdose victims. The court ultimately convicted Lewis of drug paraphernalia in a bench trial and sentenced her to three months’ probation. Lewis appealed, arguing that the court should have granted her motion to dismiss because she was immune to prosecution under the act.
What is the Drug Overdose Response Immunity Act?
Pennsylvania has a very limited statute which seeks to encourage people who observe someone else in the middle of a drug overdose to call for help instead of worrying about criminal prosecution. In order to further this goal, it provides immunity to prosecution for minor drug offenses such as the knowing and intentional possession of a controlled substance for personal use and possession of drug paraphernalia. It also provides immunity against violations of probation and parole. Notably, it does not provide immunity to serious offenses. For example, the statute does not provide immunity to Possession with the Intent to Deliver charges or the extremely serious and increasingly-prosecuted homicide charges of Drug Delivery Resulting in Death.
Can I be prosecuted if I call for help for a friend who is overdosing?
In order to qualify for immunity, the defendant must meet three criteria:
the person reported, in good faith, a drug overdose event to a law enforcement officer, the 911 system, a campus security officer or emergency services personnel and the report was made on the reasonable belief that another person was in need of immediate medical attention and was necessary to prevent death or serious bodily injury due to a drug overdose;
the person provided his own name and location and cooperated with the law enforcement officer, 911 system, campus security officer or emergency services personnel; and
the person remained with the person needing immediate medical attention until a law enforcement officer, a campus security officer or emergency services personnel arrived.
The statute further addressees the victim of the overdose. It provides:
Persons experiencing drug overdose events may not be charged and shall be immune from prosecution as provided in subsection (b) if a person who transported or reported and remained with them may not be charged and is entitled to immunity under this section.
The statute has a good purpose, but it does not protect you if you call in an overdose and have potential criminal liability for drug distribution or drug delivery resulting in death.
The Statute Applies to People Who Call For Help with Their Own Overdose
The issue in this case arose because the plain language of the statute seems to imply that a second person has called in the drug overdose on behalf of the victim. It does not directly address what should happen when there is no second person and it is the victim themselves making the phone call for help.
The Superior Court, seeking to encourage more people to seek help instead of worrying about whether they will face minor drug possession charges, held that the statute did protect the defendant in this case. The Court noticed that the Act does implicitly condition the grant of immunity on the presence of two parties: a reporter and a victim. However, the Court found that the implicit requirement was unintended. The Act does not explicitly provide immunity for self-reporters, but excluding self-reporters from the immunity granted by the Act would result in an absurd result. Under the trial court’s reasoning, Lewis would not be immune because she called 911 herself. Had she called a neighbor and asked a neighbor to call 911, Lewis would have been immune had the neighbor done so and otherwise complied with the requirements of the statute.
The Superior Court recognized that the Legislature likely did not intend this absurd result, and therefore the Act should be interpreted to apply in situations such as this where the victim and the reporter were the same person. The Court also found that the trial court was too strict in interpreting the requirement that the person actually needed immediate medical attention. Instead, the Court ruled that the person must only reasonably believe that they need immediate medical attention to avoid serious bodily injury or death. Here, there was no evidence that Lewis’s belief was unreasonable. Accordingly, the Act applied and prevented her prosecution for drug paraphernalia charges. The Superior Court reversed the conviction.
FACING CRIMINAL CHARGES? WE CAN HELP.
Philadelphia Criminal Lawyers
If you are facing criminal charges, we can help. Our Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers have successfully defended thousands of cases in state and federal courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We offer a complimentary 15-minute criminal defense strategy session to any potential client who is facing criminal charges or who may be under investigation by law enforcement. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.