Third Circuit: Pennsylvania Third-Degree Robbery Does Not Qualify as a Crime of Violence Under Federal Sentencing Guidelines

Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire - Criminal Defense Lawyer

The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has held that Pennsylvania third-degree felony robbery does not qualify as a crime of violence under the federal Sentencing Guidelines provision at issue in United States v. White, No. 22-2197 (3d Cir. Nov. 6, 2026). Pennsylvania permits a conviction under this subsection for suddenly snatching property without overcoming the victim’s resistance. Generic robbery requires that additional force. The Court therefore vacated White’s federal firearm sentence and ordered resentencing without the disputed enhancement.

What Happened in United States v. White?

In June 2020, Philadelphia police responded to reports of a burglary at a Rite Aid. Officers saw the defendant running down an aisle with a gun in his hand. An officer tackled him, arrested him, and recovered a semiautomatic pistol. The defendant pleaded guilty to possession of a firearm by a convicted felon.

At sentencing, prosecutors argued that the defendant’s prior Pennsylvania third-degree robbery conviction qualified as a crime of violence. Under U.S.S.G. § 2K2.1(a)(1), the enhancement required the qualifying firearm and at least two prior felony convictions for a crime of violence or a controlled substance offense. Both sides agreed that the defendant’s firearm could accept a large-capacity magazine and that he had one qualifying prior conviction. The robbery conviction determined whether he had the second.

The district judge counted the robbery conviction. That increased the calculated advisory range from 100–125 months to 140–175 months. Because the firearm offense carried a 120-month statutory maximum when White committed it, the advisory sentence became 120 months. The judge considered the defendant’s troubled background, granted a downward variance, and imposed 110 months. White appealed.

Why Pennsylvania’s Robbery Definition Matters

The disputed conviction fell under 18 Pa.C.S. § 3701(a)(1)(v), which prohibits taking property from another person by force however slight during a theft. The Third Circuit had already held that this offense did not satisfy the Guidelines’ elements clause, which addresses offenses requiring physical force against another person. The defendant’s appeal concerned the separate enumerated-offenses clause, which specifically lists robbery.

A state’s decision to call an offense robbery does not automatically make it a qualifying federal sentencing predicate. Under the categorical approach, the court compares the elements of the state offense with those of generic robbery. If the state permits conviction for conduct that generic robbery does not cover, the conviction cannot support the enhancement on that basis.

The Third Circuit examined how Pennsylvania courts apply the statute. Pennsylvania permits a third-degree robbery conviction when a defendant snatches a purse or takes a wallet from a person who is aware of the taking, even if the victim does not resist. Pennsylvania therefore does not require prosecutors to prove that the defendant used force to overcome resistance.

The Third Circuit Rejected the Enhancement

Generic robbery requires force sufficient to overcome a victim’s resistance. The resistance can be slight, but the defendant must overcome it. A person who simply snatches money from someone’s hand and runs away has not necessarily used that degree of force.

The difference controlled the result of the defendant’s appeal. Because Pennsylvania third-degree robbery includes sudden snatching without resistance, the state offense covers more conduct than generic robbery. The Third Circuit held that it does not qualify under the enumerated-offenses clause.

The government relied on an earlier Third Circuit decision treating North Carolina common law robbery as generic robbery. Prosecutors argued that both states required only a small amount of force. The Court rejected that comparison because North Carolina requires force sufficient to overcome resistance, while Pennsylvania permits conviction based on the force needed simply to separate the victim from the property. Describing both requirements as minimal did not make them equivalent.

The defendant was sentenced under the 2021 Guidelines, which listed robbery without defining it. The Court also addressed the Sentencing Commission’s November 2023 amendment adding a robbery definition. That amendment adopted the same requirement of force sufficient to overcome the victim’s resistance and supported the Court’s analysis.

The Court vacated the defendant’s sentence and remanded for resentencing without the § 2K2.1(a)(1) enhancement. It did not overturn his firearm conviction or his prior state robbery conviction, and it did not specify the sentence the district judge must impose on remand.

The Takeaway

Defense counsel should examine the precise subsection of every prior Pennsylvania robbery conviction before accepting a federal crime-of-violence enhancement. White addresses third-degree felony robbery under § 3701(a)(1)(v); it does not decide whether every other form of Pennsylvania robbery qualifies. For a defendant with a conviction under that subsection, counsel should challenge an enhancement based on treating it as generic robbery and calculate the range without that predicate. Counsel should preserve the objection at sentencing and pursue it on appeal if the judge incorrectly counts the conviction.

Goldstein Mehta LLC Criminal Defense

Facing Criminal Charges or Appealing a Criminal Case in Pennsylvania? We Can Help.

If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals and dismissals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, Violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and First-Degree Murder.

We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court, including the successful direct appeal of a first-degree murder conviction and the exoneration of a client who spent 33 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.

Next
Next

PA Superior Court Recognizes a Passenger’s Privacy Rights Beneath the Seat