Goldstein Mehta LLC

View Original

Bail Pending Appeal After a Criminal Conviction in Pennsylvania

Criminal Defense Lawyer Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire

Many criminal defendants who go to trial and are convicted or who plead guilty and receive a harsher sentence than expected opt to appeal their convictions and sentences to the Pennsylvania Superior Court. In general, it is usually possible to challenge both the underlying conviction as well as the resulting sentence that the judge imposed. There may be all sorts of reasons to appeal - the judge may have committed an error of law or imposed an excessive sentence, or the evidence may have been insufficient and the jury got it wrong. But criminal appeals in Pennsylvania can take time. Post-sentence motions may be decided quickly, but a full appeal to the Superior Court or beyond can take a year or two. Accordingly, we often receive questions from clients as to whether they may be eligible for bail pending sentencing or bail pending appeal.

Bail Pending Sentencing

The Pennsylvania Rules of Criminal Procedure govern bail pending appeal. Specifically, Pa.R.Crim.P. 521 deals with Bail After Finding of Guilt.

In general, the rule provides that before sentencing, a defendant who has been found guilty of an offense which is punishable by a life sentence or the death penalty shall not be released on bail.

In other cases, whether a defendant is entitled to bail pending sentencing depends on the length of the potential sentence. Prior to sentencing, where the maximum possible sentence cannot exceed three years, the defendant should presumptively remain on bail.

Where the maximum possible sentence could exceed three years, a defendant who was on bail pending trial should generally remain on bail pending sentencing unless the judges finds:

(i)   that no one or more conditions of bail will reasonably ensure that the defendant will appear and comply with the conditions of the bail bond; or

(ii)   that the defendant poses a danger to any other person or to the community or to himself or herself.

If the judge finds that either of these factors exist, the judge may revoke or deny bail. Such a ruling can be appealed to the Superior Court, but bail appeals can take a few months.

Bail Pending Appeal

After sentencing, the rules change, and the defendant’s right to bail pending appeal depends on the length of the actual sentence imposed. For a defendant who has received a county jail sentence (meaning a sentence with a maximum of less than two years), the defendant has the same right to bail pending appeal as before the trial. Again, the judge may revoke bail for the same reasons that would justify revoking bail pending sentence.

For a defendant who received a state prison sentence (meaning a sentence with a maximum longer than two years), there is no longer a right to bail pending appeal. A judge, however, retains the discretion to allow such a defendant to remain on bail pending appeal where the judge thinks it’s appropriate.

For both groups of defendants, the judge can obviously require the defendant to actually file post-sentence motions and/or the actual appeal in order to remain on bail.

Finally, the rules require the judge to state the reasons for the denial or revocation of bail on the record so that the defendant may seek review in the Superior Court by filing a petition for specialized review should the defendant wish to appeal the bail ruling. The petition for specialized review is a separate appeal to the Superior Court which will usually be resolved more quickly than the full appeal.

Changes in Bail Conditions

It is important to note that in either case, a defendant who receives bail pending appeal may not receive the exact same bail. The judge could change the conditions or increase the bail.

Additionally, this rule does not typically apply to defendants who have appealed from a judgment of the Philadelphia Municipal Court. The Municipal Court has its own unique appeal procedures in which the defendant may seek a trial de novo. Filling a notice of appeal for a trial de novo actually vacates the original conviction, so the defendant then remains on the same pre-trial bail that existed prior to trial.

The rules for bail pending sentencing and bail pending appeal depend on the potential sentence and the actual sentence imposed. Short sentences for less serious offenses will typically allow for bail pending appeal, while judges are much less likely to grant bail pending appeal in serious cases or for cases involving lengthy sentences.

Bail Pending PCRA

Finally, the rules are silent on whether a defendant may be entitled to bail while a Post-Conviction Relief Act Petition is pending. In general, most defendants will not receive bail during PCRA litigation. The case law, however, does provide judges the authority to release a defendant on bail pending PCRA litigation when the judge believes the petition has strong merit. This is much less common than bail pending appeal, but it is not out of the question should the petitioner have a particularly strong PCRA issue.


Facing criminal charges or appealing a conviction? We can help.

Philadelphia Criminal Defense Attorney Zak T. Goldstein, Esquire

If you are facing criminal charges or under investigation by the police, we can help. We have successfully defended thousands of clients against criminal charges in courts throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey. We have successfully obtained full acquittals in cases involving charges such as Conspiracy, Aggravated Assault, Rape, and Murder. We have also won criminal appeals and PCRAs in state and federal court. Our award-winning Philadelphia criminal defense lawyers offer a free criminal defense strategy session to any potential client. Call 267-225-2545 to speak with an experienced and understanding defense attorney today.